Can I Return an Engagement Ring?

Table of Contents

An engagement ring is a very important personal possession as well as a financial investment. It is meant to be a symbol of your relationship and a touchstone for your lifelong commitment.

Unfortunately, under some circumstances, it may become necessary to return an engagement ring.

Once married, some couples may experience financial difficulties and choose to exchange an engagement ring for cash. After many years, the wearer of the ring may want to replace it with something that suits their current style.

Two painful reasons for attempting to return a ring are a broken engagement or an ending marriage.

In this article, we discuss your prospects for returning an engagement ring.

Can I Return an Engagement Ring?

Upon identifying who has ownership of the engagement ring, you can begin the process of returning it.

Some establishments have return policies that span 30 days to one year after the original purchase date. Some stores may only accept a swap for a similar or higher-valued item instead of a reimbursement.

Some stores may simply refuse to accept ring returns regardless of circumstance.

Even stores with flexible return policies may not allow you to return a ring due to the following:

  • The ring has been customized or repaired in any way
  • The ring was sold during a clearance sale
  • Lack of important paperwork

What Is The Return Policy for Engagement Rings?

Each business has its own return policy, something you should have done your due diligence on when you were shopping for the ring. The establishment must be clear on the exact terms, restrictions, and time constraints for returns.

If you want or need to return your ring within a few weeks of buying it, you should be able to get a refund from many big stores (both in-store and web-based). Depending on where you purchased the ring, you should be able to return it within 30 to 60 days.

If months or years have passed, some small, local jewelers may still swap or refund your ring, but most will not.

Consult with these businesses to see what policies they have in place and if they have advice for what you can do with the ring, such as selling the ring to a pawn shop or eBay.


Can You Return an Engagement Ring if She Doesn’t Like It?

A marriage proposal is one of the most important moments in any person’s life. It is exhilarating to ask or be asked the big question, and it is such a joyful moment to hear or say an excited “yes!”

Once the joy of the proposal has passed, it’s time to get your bearings and consider the ring. What if you dislike it after one look? What if it’s not to your style at all? What if you are allergic to the metal band?

There are many reasons why an engagement ring may not be suited for the one who received it. If this happens, it’s best to discuss the situation logically as partners.

This is a very sensitive subject for the person who bought the ring, and it’s best to tread carefully and be as kind as possible.

If you decide to return the engagement ring, you can discuss your options with your jeweler. Perhaps a resize or redesign will be better instead of a replacement.

If you are still within the return period, make sure to bring all the necessary documentation for the transaction. Their specific store policy will determine the next steps you need to take.

Should an Engagement Ring Be Returned?

If the engagement has ended and the ring was returned to the person who bought it, it may seem like a rational, cost-effective decision to keep it and reuse it in the future.

After all, it’s an asset that you should be free to use however you like. But no matter how pragmatic you are, this is not a great idea.

An engagement ring is a symbol of a deep relationship between two people. It was bought for one specific person as an expression of commitment and a promise of building a new life together.

It will be hurtful to the next partner if they discover that the ring was initially intended for someone else.

If an engagement ring is not being used for any reason, it’s best to return it to the jeweler if possible, sell it off at a pawnshop, or donate it.

How Long Do You Have to Return an Engagement Ring?

Jewelry retailers all have different return policies. As such, you must carefully read through or discuss the terms and conditions related to exchanges and returns before you purchase an engagement ring.


Othergems Return Policy

At Othergems, every piece of jewelry we sell is backed by our guarantee. We understand the difficulties of purchasing online, and we place a high value on customer happiness.

If you are not completely happy with your jewelry, you may return it for cash or get a replacement within 30 days of receiving it. This is not inclusive of orders that are manufactured for custom designs.

Refunds would be applied to the original method of payment.

If you wish to exchange or return something after this timespan, it would be at the company’s discretion. For more reading about our terms, click here

Why Buy an Engagement Ring at

When you purchase an engagement ring from, you can rest assured that you will receive the best possible product and experience high-quality customer service. All our diamonds are accurately graded and of pristine condition.

Our return policies are very accommodating, so if any mishaps or unforeseen circumstances occur, just reach out to us, and we can help.

We have more than 30 years of experience in the diamond jewelry industry. We have a streamlined process for speedy, high-end ring production, short delivery times, and expert customer service. We ship internationally, and we will bring your dream custom diamond jewelry to life.

Share this post

Shopping cart
Sign in

No account yet?

Start typing to see products you are looking for.

Diamond Color Chart

Color is one of the four important factors that determine the value and quality of a diamond (carat, color, clarity and cut grade). The colors range from D which is colorless, all the way through Z which is a light yellow or brown. The more colorless a diamond is, the more it is rare and expensive.

D, E, F


G, H


I, J










Diamond Clarity Chart

Clarity is one of the four important factors that determine the value and quality of a diamond (carat, color, clarity and cut grade). Almost every diamond has inclusions in it, and that’s what makes it unique. The shape, placement and amount of inclusions determine the clarity of a diamond. The highest level of clarity is FL and the lowest is I3.








VS1, VS2


SI1 & SI2,SI3


I1,I2& I3


Ring size guide

Still unsure? Check out our Ring Size Guide

We stand behind every jewelry we sell. We are aware of the challenges of shopping online, and customer satisfaction is our top priority.


Therefore, if for some reason you are not a 100 percent satisfied with your jewelry, you can return it free of charge within 30 days of arrival for a full refund or exchange. This does not include custom-made orders.


Refunds will be credited to the original form of payment you made. 


If you wish to make an exchange or return after this time frame, it will be at the discretion of the company.


Free cancellation within 2 hours of the time of purchase.